Insurance Europe concerned about the new EC collective interests of consumer's protection Directive potential effects

Insurance Europe is concerned about the implications of the European Commission's proposal for a Directive on representative actions for the protection of the collective interests of consumers, which was published on April 11.

The proposal would repeal the 2009 Injunctions Directive and govern how consumers launch collective legal actions against organizations, such as insurers.

William VIDONJA, head of conduct of business at Insurance Europe, commented: "While welcoming the Commission's focus on strengthening the enforcement of EU consumer law, it is disappointing that the Commission's own 2013 recommendations, which set out a strong basis to develop collective mechanisms in member states, have not been adhered to."

"In the latest proposals, good principles that the Commission promoted to safeguard against the potential abuse of collective mechanisms - such as that the loser pays the costs of litigation and that consumers should actively choose to participate in collective actions - are compromised," he added.

Ensuring proper safeguards exist is important in light of the proposal's wide-reaching implications. A successful application establishing a breach of EU law covered by the proposal can be relied on in any subsequent redress action.

The Commission's proposals address concerns that collective actions could become investment opportunities for third-party funders with no interest in the outcome of proceedings, other than the return on investment. However, it underestimates the risk that awards can be diverted to third-party funders, instead of to claimants seeking redress.

Without proper safeguards, there could be a proliferation in collective actions motivated by the potential return on investment, rather than the legitimacy of a claim. This could increase business operating costs, to the detriment of both European consumers and insurers.

VIDONJA adds: "Insurance Europe is not yet persuaded of the need for such a wide-ranging proposal. This is because many member states have only recently introduced, or are in the process of introducing, collective redress mechanisms. More time is therefore necessary to see how these mechanisms function in different legal systems and how effective the safeguards against possible abuse are."

InsuranceEurope press release

Follow XPRIMM Publications on LinkedIn, for more data on the insurance and financial industry.

Share |

Related articles

20 years with XPRIMM

Our journey alongside the CEE, SEE and CIS insurance markets has reached the 20th milestone.
In 20 years we made every effort to become a reliable source of information, a familiar presence wherever something important happens in the re/insurance world.

2018-07-10

Deutsche Ruck grows and strengthens its assets

The Deutsche Ruck Group's gross premium income rose by 2.3% to EUR 1.2 billion in 2017. As well as a slight improvement in the operating result before tax, the Group once again achieved good investment income.

2018-07-11

LIVE: IIS Global Insurance Forum 2018 / Day2

The works of the Global Insurance Forum continued today in Berlin, Germany. Providing security for ageing populations in health care and pensions terms, as well as innovation and InsurTech or innovative strategies for the future development of the industry are on the today's agenda.

2018-07-10

IIS Global Insurance Forum 2018 / Day1: The innovation transformation of insurance

We have gathered the representatives of all stakeholders in the insurance industry from more than 50 countries to enhance exchanging ideas and offer solutions to international community about new technologies and to share knowledge, stated Mike MORRISSEY, President and CEO, International Insurance Society at the annual edition of the Global Insurance Forum.

2018-07-09

ON THE MOVE

JLT FAC expands global team

JLT FAC, part of JLT Re, a global provider of reinsurance broking and consultancy has appointed two senior executives in London and its U.S. team.

04.07.2018

UPDATE: Inga BEALE to leave Lloyd's in 2019

Lloyd's has confirmed on 29 June Dame Inga BEALE's departure. She will step down next year after leading the global insurance and reinsurance market for five years, at a date that will be confirmed in due course.

02.07.2018

Inga BEALE may leave Lloyd's by the end of the year

Although neither Lloyd's or Inga BEALE made any official statement, market rumors say the current head of the London's most renowned reinsurance entity will step down at the end of the year, as reported by the press.

29.06.2018

TOP EVENT

LIVE: IIS Global Insurance Forum 2018 / Day2

The works of the Global Insurance Forum continued today in Berlin, Germany. Providing security for ageing populations in health care and pensions terms, as well as innovation and InsurTech or innovative strategies for the future development of the industry are on the today's agenda.

10.07.2018

See all