Consumer protection in an increasingly digital financial market requires a shift from reacting to problems towards preventing them, while ensuring that innovation delivers genuine benefits to consumers. This was one of the central messages of Petra Hielkema, Chairperson of the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA), in her closing remarks at the 13th Joint ESAs Consumer Protection Day, held in Rome on 4 November 2026.
Organised by the three European Supervisory Authorities (EIOPA, EBA and ESMA), with the support of Banca d”Italia, the event brought together regulators, financial industry representatives and consumer organisations to discuss fair access to financial services, product oversight, consumer redress and the opportunities and challenges associated with artificial intelligence.
Reflecting on the day's discussions, Hielkema emphasised that trust remains fundamental to a well-functioning European single market. While supervisors have an important role in maintaining that trust, financial services providers also have a direct interest in ensuring that consumers are treated fairly and receive appropriate products.
Fairness, she argued, extends beyond simply allowing consumers to access financial services. It also means ensuring that products are affordable, suitable for their needs and available without unjustified barriers.
Hielkema also questioned whether traditional approaches to financial advice should remain the only route towards greater consumer participation in savings and investment products. Referring to pension systems where automatic enrolment and default arrangements have proved effective, she suggested that simpler solutions could help consumers achieve better financial outcomes without necessarily requiring extensive individual advice.
From reacting to complaints to preventing consumer harm
A particularly strong message concerned the need to move beyond identifying problematic products and responding to complaints towards anticipating and preventing consumer detriment.
Hielkema acknowledged the importance of existing product monitoring procedures, including those used by insurers and other financial institutions to identify outliers and address problems. However, she stressed that product oversight should also consider whether products remain appropriate as markets and consumer expectations evolve.
Drawing attention to the long-lasting consequences of financial mis-selling scandals, she warned that failures in consumer protection can undermine confidence for decades.
The challenge, therefore, is not merely to ensure that products comply with today's requirements, but to anticipate whether they will remain suitable in tomorrow's increasingly digital financial environment.
"Are we working on fit for purpose or are we working for fit for future?" she asked, challenging policymakers and industry representatives to consider whether new legislation is designed for a genuinely integrated, digital European market or simply preserves existing practices.
Complaints and consumer redress remain essential safeguards, but they represent the final stages of consumer protection rather than its starting point.
Hielkema also acknowledged the sometimes difficult balance between conduct supervision, which may require compensation for affected consumers, and prudential supervision, which must ensure that financial institutions maintain sufficient capital.
Nevertheless, her central message was clear: preventing consumer harm should take priority over correcting problems after they have occurred.
AI challenges traditional approaches to consumer responsibility
Artificial intelligence featured prominently in Hielkema's concluding reflections.
She observed that the rapid adoption of generative AI is already changing how consumers interact with financial services, while supervisors and providers are struggling to keep pace.
Traditionally, the regulatory response to emerging technologies has often begun with warnings, restrictions and attempts to transfer responsibility to consumers. However, Hielkema argued that such an approach cannot provide a sustainable answer to the widespread use of AI.
"We can warn against it, it won't stop people from asking questions," she said, referring to consumers increasingly turning to AI systems for financial information and advice.
In her view, the challenge is to move beyond warnings and exclusions and determine how AI can be responsibly integrated into financial services, including the way products are offered, advice is provided and consumer outcomes are supervised.
She also questioned the tendency to place excessive responsibility on consumers for understanding complex financial products.
In the past, consumers were expected to read lengthy disclosures and develop sufficient financial literacy to make informed decisions. With AI, there is a risk that this expectation will simply be replaced by the requirement to formulate better questions and prompts.
Hielkema challenged this approach, asking whether financial institutions and supervisors should instead take greater responsibility for providing straightforward solutions that genuinely benefit consumers without requiring them to understand every technical detail.
The human dimension of insurance remains essential
While recognising AI's considerable potential, Hielkema also highlighted an important competitive advantage of human interaction, particularly in insurance.
Using the example of a family stranded during a holiday after a hailstorm damages their car, she described the value of having someone answer the telephone, listen to the customer's difficulties and help them find a practical solution.
Empathy and reassurance, she suggested, remain essential elements of insurance services, especially when customers are dealing with unexpected losses and stressful situations.
At the same time, she acknowledged that AI will continue to develop and could provide increasingly sophisticated assistance and advice.
Rather than resisting this transformation, supervisors and financial institutions should work together to understand its implications and establish appropriate safeguards.
BEUC calls for stronger product supervision and comparable data
The need for more effective consumer protection was also emphasised by Agustín Reyna, Director General of the European Consumer Organisation (BEUC), who questioned whether disclosure-based regulation can adequately address structural problems in financial markets.
Reyna argued that low consumer engagement, limited supervisory intervention powers and insufficient commercial incentives to improve outcomes can allow unsuitable financial products to remain on the market.
He noted that supervisors have progressively developed tools such as value-for-money assessments and benchmarking, but still face difficulties in achieving meaningful improvements.
One of the priorities, in his view, should be the availability of comparable data on financial product performance across EU Member States, allowing supervisors to identify problems and intervene before they develop into major consumer protection scandals.
Reyna also stressed that simplicity should become a central objective in financial product design and supervision, arguing that making financial services easier to understand can improve both consumer outcomes and market efficiency.
Consumer protection as a foundation for market confidence
Opening the broader discussion from the perspective of financial stability and market development, Sergio Nicoletti Altimari, Deputy Governor of Banca d'Italia, underlined that consumer protection is not simply a question of fairness, but an essential condition for well-functioning financial markets.
Fair treatment, clear information and suitable products help build consumer confidence, reduce information asymmetries and support effective competition, ultimately contributing to the stability and resilience of the financial system.
He also highlighted the opportunities offered by digitalisation and AI, including more personalised products, improved fraud detection and more efficient complaints handling. However, these benefits require reliable data, appropriate safeguards and stronger financial and digital literacy.
A shared responsibility for future-proof consumer protection
Concluding the event, Hielkema called for closer cooperation between supervisors, financial institutions and consumer organisations to address challenges that are not necessarily new in substance, but are emerging at unprecedented speed.
The objective, she suggested, should be to ensure that technological innovation, effective supervision and better-designed financial products contribute to stronger savings, improved pension outcomes and a more efficient European single market.
Her remarks highlighted an increasingly important direction for European financial regulation: consumer protection should be assessed not only through compliance with disclosure and conduct requirements, but through the actual outcomes delivered to consumers — and the ability to prevent harm before it occurs.
XPRIMM Insurance Publications was represented at the event by Daniela GHETU, Editorial Director.
EIOPA's Petra Hielkema: Consumer protection must move beyond warnings and disclosure to prevent harm
4 November 2026 — Daniela GHETU
3201 views