MAI: We need to re-analyze the premiums, the mandatory insured sums and the payment facilities offered to certain social categories"MAI is re-analyzing, together with the other actors involved, the fixed level of insurance premiums and of maximum mandatory insured value and it is trying to identify efficient solutions for managing the mandatory household insurance", Marin ARMASELU, Director of Cabinet, Ministry of Administration and Interior said in the opening of ICAR 2012 - The International CAtastrophic Risks Forum.
Also, it is necessary to reevaluate the premium payment facilities offered to social assisted families, lodgers associations, those that renew their policy before the current one expires or in the case of collective policies, Marin ARMASELU added.
The Prefect of Bucharest: The institutions and specialists must involve more in prevention actions by informing the population
According to lists updated at the half of August 2012, 2,534 buildings from Bucharest were evaluated as far as earthquake risk is concerned, Georgeta GAVRILA, Prefect, Bucharest Prefecture, announced during ICAR Forum 2012. Of all these, only 147 buildings with 1,582 evaluated apartments were not placed in earthquake risk or emergency categories. Thus, 1,638 buildings with 5,007 apartments were placed in the emergency category, and the remaining 749 buildings, with 18,286 apartments, in different earthquake risk categories. Of these, 374 buildings with 5,842 apartments present high risk of crashing during an earthquake, and 300 buildings with 10,768 apartments a lower risk, but major structural damage is expected.
"The safety of earthquake exposed buildings depends on the efficient collaboration between involved institutions and on the way the owners and administrators of these buildings understand their own duties. Thus, the mandatory household insurance law is more than welcomed", the Prefect of Bucharest declared.
Cornel COCA-CONSTANTINESCU: The cut-throat competition among insurers led to the decline of household insurance underwritings
"2012 brings a decrease of household insurance underwritings due to a fierce competition among insurers and a decline of the mandatory household insurance contracts signed by PAID. Voluntary insurance has a significant influence on the insurance coverage, but it implies a selection of the covered risks, generating voluntary insurance especially in low risk areas and a high density of mandatory insurance for PAID in vulnerable areas", Cornel COCA-CONSTANTINESCU, Vice-president, CSA (The Romanian Insurance Supervisory Commission) explained.
According to CSA data, after the first six half of 2012, 44% of the Romanian houses were not covered by insurance. The rest of 56-57% have either mandatory insurance (5.1%) or voluntary insurance (51%).
Aurelia CRISTEA: We find ourselves in a situation where the law cannot be applied for the purpose it was created
"We find ourselves in a situation where the law [Law nr. 260/2008] cannot be applied for the purpose it was created (...). The legislative instability on the insurance market generated a competition between PAID and its shareholders. This determined the apparition of irregular catastrophe risks coverage conditions and a severe decrease of insurance premium on the household segment", Aurelia CRISTEA, General Manager of PAID, said during ICAR Forum 2012.
"The exposure dynamics undertaken by PAID and the other reinsurance companies is unpredictable, and the uncertainty determines an increase in reinsurance costs, the specialized companies being reluctant to involve in an unstable context", Aurelia CRISTEA added.
Cristian CONSTANTINESCU: Social protection cannot be made through private capital!
The law was based on a completely wrong principle: social protection cannot be made through private capital, Cristian CONSTANTINESCU, well-known professional on the Romanian insurance market, affirmed. "If we talk about social protection, PAID should become a state-owned company, supported by the Government, and thus we put an end to this madness. There would be no more differences between companies member of PAID and those that are not a member as far as the selling of voluntary household insurance is concerned, which violated the free competition right, given the fact that PAID's main competitors were actually the PAID shareholders themselves".
"We should pick the least bad thing of all, and I am thinking, first and foremost, to the clients, not to PAID, insurers or CSA", Cristian CONSTANTINESCU continued. The solution is only one policy for the insured, the premium to be paid to one company, and that company to cede the corresponding premium for the three catastrophe risks, of 10 or 20 EUR, to PAID", CONSTANTINESCU suggested.
Romeo JANTEA: PAID policies must be bought, not sold
Being mandatory, the PAID policies should be bought, not sold, Romeo JANTEA, Vice-president, UNIQA Asigurari, considers. "Every house owner has a contract for the electricity services, through which the public radio taxes is collected. The PAID policy could be collected in a similar manner", he proposed during ICAR Forum 2012.
According to the Vice-president of UNIQA Asigurari, the insurers' lack of interest for the selling of these policies is a normal attitude, given the fact that, because of the difficult economic context, they are barely selling their own insurance products.
"I do not think that the insurers are interested in selling these mandatory household policies, taking into account the actual commissions (10% of the premium, representing 2 or 1 EUR)", Romeo JANTEA added.
Bogdan ANDRIESCU: The Romanians' perception that a voluntary policy has a 20 EUR price is harmful
The system had an important positive role, given the fact that the insurance coverage reached 56%, according to Bogdan ANDRIESCU, President of UNSICAR. "On the other hand, the Romanians' perception that a voluntary policy has a 20 EUR price is a negative aspect of the situation and it is harmful for all the clients in general, but especially for those that live in areas with high earthquake exposure", he added. UNSICAR suggested a 10% tax discount for the owners that have a household insurance.
Regarding the insurance brokers' role in this mandatory household insurance system, Cristian BALANICA, General Manager, PIRAEUS Insurance Broker, considers that brokers are only selling these policies respecting the law, but this law must be clear.
"We need credibility and consistency because, as a brokerage agency part of a financial group, it's difficult to make a mandatory insurance for 20,000 clients and one week later the law to be suspended. We must avoid situations like these, because as intermediaries, we are placed in rather weird circumstances", the leader of PIRAEUS Insurance Broker noted.
The reinsurers have difficulties in setting the catastrophic risks rates because of the legislative uncertainty
"We have a problem. We talk about the necessity of a coherent legislative framework. Many companies see it as an uncertain element in next year's planning. No local company can cover all the risks by itself, and the representatives of international reinsurers began to ask themselves how to rate", Adrian MARIN, CEO, GENERALI Romania, declared.
Past legislative regulations allowed the apparition of a strong competition between mandatory and voluntary household insurance policies, because the law allowed an insured person to opt for a voluntary insurance that covered the three catastrophic risks. At the same time, voluntary household insurance products with prices similar to PAD but with more covered risks were launched on the market.
Arthur BOROWINSKI: We need stability for a year at least
"We need market stability for a year at least, if not for more. For VIG, Romania is the riskiest country as far as natural catastrophes are concerned", Arthur BOROWINSKI, Vicepresident, OMNIASIG VIG, said.
"If household insurance is mandatory, it brings us benefits on the voluntary insurance segment as well. We are waiting for the final legislative regulation. On the local market we have a correct estimation of risks, appropriate tariffs and we have a good portfolio which we wish to keep", BOROWINSKI added.
UNSAR prepares an action plan in case of natural catastrophe
UNSAR intends to implement an action procedure in case of a natural catastrophe, to which the association's members can join optionally, aiming to help the insured faster and more efficiently. The procedure is still in a project stage, requiring approval from the Competition Council because of its unitary character.
"At UNSAR, we have initiated an action that will help us understand better if and how we will react after a catastrophic event. We also sent a survey so that the companies act in a similar way. Certain steps must be approved by the Competition Council, to see if they affect the price of polices", said Adrian MARIN, CEO, GENERALI Romania, and Responsible for Property Insurance at UNSAR.
SWISS Re: It is good Romania took preventive steps before any major event
"There is a big difference between insured losses and economic losses. It is a huge burden for those countries that have not sufficient coverage. Any preventive step towards this direction helps a country reduce its exposure in case of natural disasters and there are financially available that can cover these risks. The good news is that Romania took preventive steps on the insurance domain before any such major event", Michael FUCHS, Director, SWISS Re Europe, declared.
"At the moment, the attention is focused on the earthquake risk, which is the most important for Romania, but unfortunately, it is not the only one. We have seen that floods can be even more dangerous", he added.
Guy HUDSON: I have the feeling that a resolution is closer than we think
"Five years ago, nobody believed that the household insurance market will have a penetration rate of more than 50% in Romania. In spite of the questions regarding its viability and sustainability, it is a remarkable achievement. If we look at the global situation, all the similar structures are different, reflecting the legislative necessities of every country. I have the feeling that a resolution is closer than we think", Guy HUDSON, Partner, JLT Re, declared.
"It's interesting to discuss the situation of mandatory household insurance in Romania and leaving without knowing what will happen next. Everybody knows that something professional must be done, something that should be a defining step towards the creation of a working structure", Guy HUDSON explained.
Click here for ICAR Forum 2012 photo gallery
8950 views